Skip to Main Content

Critical Reasoning Example #2

Mike McGarry
Lesson by Mike McGarry
Magoosh Expert
Summary
The lesson focuses on a critical reasoning problem, aiming to teach GMAT prep students how to weaken an argument by analyzing a specific scenario involving the wages of factory workers at Hamport Steelworks.
  • The lesson begins with a presentation of a critical reasoning question, asking which option would weaken the industry analyst's argument regarding wage increases and cost of living adjustments.
  • An industry analyst argues that the revenue generated by factory workers could be redistributed to provide a more livable wage, which is countered by the factory owners' claim of economic constraints.
  • The lesson dissects each answer choice, demonstrating why options strengthen or weaken the analyst's argument, concluding that only one option effectively challenges the analyst's stance.
  • The correct answer, which suggests that revenue is tied up in necessary marketing efforts, directly weakens the analyst's argument by highlighting economic limitations to wage redistribution.
  • The lesson emphasizes the importance of understanding the logic behind each question and encourages watching video explanations for each question to grasp the underlying reasoning.
Chapters
00:00
Introduction to Critical Reasoning Problem
00:32
Analyzing the Argument and Identifying the Task
02:23
Dissecting Answer Choices
05:08
Conclusion and Correct Answer
05:26
Lesson Recap and Advice